‘Downsizing the QEII was a mistake’: Reaction after Welwyn Garden City hospital graded inadequate

PUBLISHED: 09:42 25 July 2018 | UPDATED: 09:42 25 July 2018

The QEII Hospital in Welwyn Garden City [Picture: Alan Davies]

The QEII Hospital in Welwyn Garden City [Picture: Alan Davies]

Alan Davies

Local health chiefs have come under fire after Welwyn Garden City’s New QEII Hospital was graded inadequate.

The CQC found surgery services at Stevenages Lister Hospital to be inadequate when it comes to being safe and well-led. Picture: Danny LooThe CQC found surgery services at Stevenages Lister Hospital to be inadequate when it comes to being safe and well-led. Picture: Danny Loo

The Care Quality Commission also judged Lister Hospital as ‘requires improvement’ in last week’s report, following which critics claimed downsizing the QEII despite widespread opposition in 2014 was a mistake.

A QEII worker told the WHT that she believed it has caused both hospitals to struggle, which has been reflected in the CQC ratings ever since.

“I think it’s sad the old QEII went down,” she said. “I understand the reasons behind it but I do believe doing away with the A&E was the wrong decision.”

Since the downsizing, the New QEII has been graded ‘requires improvement’ and ‘inadequate’, while Lister has been judged ‘requires improvement’ twice.

Denis Hawes. Picture: Chris Flanagan.Denis Hawes. Picture: Chris Flanagan.

But the East and North Herts Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG), which is responsible for planning and funding of local healthcare, pointed to how the New QEII’s Urgent Care Centre treats twice as many patients daily as the old A&E did.

A spokeswoman said that A&E and maternity services – which were both centralised at Lister – were graded ‘good’, despite the backdrop of rising national demand.

Waiting times for patients at the UCC, which is designed to treat minor problems, remain comparatively short and patients found staff caring, she added.

But Denis Hawes, 79, said: “I think it was a mistake to downgrade it – it’s not really a hospital anymore.

“It’s more a clinic that does some functions.”

However, Mr Hawes was among many residents to heap praise on the “fantastic staff” doing their best at both hospitals.

Welwyn Hatfield MP Grant Shapps, who is campaigning for healthcare services to be closer to the borough, said the QEII is not getting the focus it needs.

“I recently spoke to health bosses about my concerns and expect them to take urgent action to address the shortcomings,” he said.

But Labour councillor Max Holloway criticised Mr Shapps’ “meaningless slogans and empty promises”, adding: “It shouldn’t come as a surprise to anyone that the NHS is struggling.

“This is a Conservative government that has starved the service of resources while somehow expecting it to carry on as normal.”

Related articles

More news stories

A man who was fatally stabbed in a block of flats in Welwyn Garden City was “in the wrong place at the wrong time”, a court has heard today.

12 minutes ago

A judge has ruled that there is ‘no case to answer’ after former Tesco executives were accused of leading the Welwyn Garden City-based company to overstate its profits by £250million.

Four commemorative trees have been planted in memory of former Welwyn Hatfield councillors.

The Government’s Brexit vote is said to be delayed, with Welwyn Hatfield’s MP Grant Shapps one of many Conservative MPs who were considering giving Theresa May a crushing defeat.

Newsletter Sign Up

Welwyn Hatfield Times weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most read stories

Hot Jobs

Show Job Lists

Herts Most Wanted Herts Business Awards