‘Sherlock Holmes’ and the curious case of Welwyn Garden City man George Edalji

06:00 17 June 2013

George Edalji

George Edalji


WHAT do Sherlock Holmes, Welwyn Garden City and a curious case of animal cruelty, which outraged the nation, all have in common?

Solicitor General on Edalji case

SOLICITOR General and North East Hertfordshire MP Oliver Heald spoke of the groundbreaking watershed case of George Edalji.

Mr Heald, the country’s second most senior legal appointee, told the Welwyn Hatfield Times: “It was an important case in its time and led to changes in the criminal justice system.”

Mr Heald said how Edalji’s conviction was such a farce that he was convicted of injuring animals, which were slashed while he was already in prison.

And the MP speculated that Edalji may have fingered because the family were “outsiders to the village”, being Asians living in “a small society”, Great Wyrley, in Staffordshire.

Mr Heald also said Edalji’s father’s conversion from Parsee to Christianity, and his eventual appointment as the vicar may have angered traditionalists.

he answer is George Edalji, who died six decades ago today.

The Welwyn Garden City resident was exonerated of horse-ripping and injuring other animals, thanks to real-life detective work by Sherlock Holmes creator Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.

Edalji was wrongly convicted of the infamous ‘Wyrley Outrages’, and went on to live in WGC, where he died in 1953.

He was born in 1876, the son of the vicar Great Wyrley, in Staffordshire, and eventually came to live in Brocket Close, off Valley Road, from around 1930.

Edalji came to national prominence when he was arrested and convicted of injuring animals in 1903.

The resulting furore caused a sensation, as a series of slashings of horses, cows and sheep revolted the nation.

In October 1903, Edalji was tried and convicted for the eighth attack, on a pit pony, and sentenced to seven years with hard labour.

His family had been the victims of a long-running campaign of untraceable abusive letters and anonymous harassment in 1888 and 1892 to 1895.

Further letters alleged he was partially responsible for the ‘outrages’, which caused police suspicion to focus on him as their prime suspect.

Edalji was subsequently released in 1906 after a series of dignitaries pleaded his case, but he was not pardoned, and the police kept him under surveillance.

It was at this point that the creator of the deerstalker-clad detective of 221B Baker Street took up the case.

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was persuaded to ‘turn detective’ to prove Edalji’s innocence. And, after eight months of sleuthing, Conan Doyle achieved his aim and Edalji was exonerated by a Home Office committee of enquiry, though no compensation was awarded. Possibly due to the poisonous treatment of the family in Great Wyrley, which included the abusive letters, they moved to Welwyn Garden City.

Shaun O’Reilly, chairman of the WGC Society, believes it is the town’s enlightened outlook which attracted the Anglo-Indian family to the area.

He told the Welwyn Hatfield Times: “He may have come to live here as he found it a forward thinking place in those days that may have been free of prejudice.”

And Mr O’Reilly said the miscarriage of justice that led to Edalji’s conviction had had a lasting legacy.

“His own case gave rise to the setting up of a criminal Court of Criminal Appeal and we must all be grateful to him for that,” he added.


John Lewis Welwyn Garden City at Christmas

There are just four shopping days left to Christmas. Here are the opening hours for major stores and supermarket chains in Hatfield, Welwyn Garden City and Potters Bar, Hertfordshire, over the 2014 Christmas and New Year holiday period.

Do you recognise any of Hertfordshire's Most Wanted?

Recognise any of the new faces pictured in our police Hertfordshire Most Wanted gallery?

Yesterday, 13:56
A witness appeal has been launched following a head-on collision on the B197. Picture: @RoadpoliceBCH via Twitter.

A witness appeal has been launched after a head-on collision this morning which has left one of the drivers with a serious leg injuries.

Yesterday, 12:47
Traffic is heavy on the A1(M) heading southbound.

Traffic remains heavy on the A1(M) after a multi-car crash this morning.

Most read stories

Most commented stories