Hatfield author’s new book on Captain Scott’s ‘invaluable’ helper

12:51 26 January 2012

Petty officer Edgar Evans was the first of the five men to die on the Terra Nova expedition

Petty officer Edgar Evans was the first of the five men to die on the Terra Nova expedition

Archant

A NEW book by a retired Hatfield doctor has thrown new light on Captain Scott’s ill fated 1912 expedition to the South Pole.

Former physician Isobel Williams wants to end an enduring myth about the legendary voyage and one of its central figures – petty officer Edgar “Taff” Evans.

She believes Evans’ perception as a weak-minded drunkard whose own demise caused the deaths of his colleagues Scott, Lawrence Oates, Edgar Wilson and Henry Bowers, is wide of the mark.

Her book, Captain Scott’s Invaluable Assistant, Edgar Evans, claims he was actually a key player in the expedition, who was instrumental in getting the team to the South Pole, and whose death played no part in the fate of his comrades.

“He was very much castigated for holding up the rest of the party, and inadvertently causing the deaths of all the people he admired,” Dr Williams said.

“This criticism is devastating and not true. He was tough, organised, strong, humorous and very practical.”

Captain Scott agreed. Writing in his journal, he described Evans as “a giant worker” and an “invaluable assistant” and praised his organisational skills.

But on the 1912 expedition, Evans cut his hand shortly before reaching the South Pole, a wound which failed to heal properly.

On the return journey – after discovering they’d been beaten to the South Pole by Norwegian explorer Roald Amundsen – the men were hit by atrocious weather, and Evans’ mental and physical condition deteriorated. After injuring his head, Evans died on February 17, 1912.

A month later, a weakening Oates sacrificed himself in a bid to give the remaining three a fighting chance of survival, but Scott, Wilson and Bowers eventually succumbed to the freezing temperatures in late March.

But the deaths of the last four men were not the result of Evans’ own – the terrible weather and the insufficient diet were to blame, according to Dr Williams.

“I think he should be remembered for the remarkable things he did,” she said.

Captain Scott’s Invaluable Assistant, Edgar Evans is published by The History Press, priced £12.99

1 comment

  • Here's the thing. For all his human frailties, Taff, in common with all those intrepid explorers, was quite simply a remarkable individual. It is the ultimate human failure to always require a scapegoat in circumstances of tragedy. It's clear there were numerous reasons for the failure of those 5 brave men to return from the Pole. We should all be in awe of explorers from the Heroic Age of Antarctic Exploration. They were made of sterner stuff and those commentators searching for the sensational, should be satisfied that these men were simply giants in the history of exploration and science.

    Report this comment

    arcticfox

    Saturday, January 28, 2012

Yesterday, 17:04
Sir Oliver Heald Photo: Palace Photos.

An A1(M) “bottleneck” between WGC and Stevenage is affecting several constituencies and damaging national infrastructure, the House of Commons has been told.

Mon, 15:40
Police were called after blood was found in a public toilet in Hatfield

A large amount of blood discovered in a public toilet in Hatfield prompted a police investigation over the weekend.

Mon, 11:50
Police have appealed for information after a vulnerable man was robbed

A 40-year-old man, described by police as vulnerable, had his arm twisted behind his back in a vicious robbery in Hatfield.

Mon, 10:48
Police are appealing for witnesses.

A woman was flagged down and conned close to the M25 in South Mimms, prompting a police appeal.

Most read stories

Most commented stories

E-edition