Anger over Welwyn Garden City hospice homemade cake ban

PUBLISHED: 11:24 22 August 2013 | UPDATED: 16:22 22 August 2013

Maggie & John Molyneux

Maggie & John Molyneux


ANGER is rising over a Welwyn Garden City charity’s ban on home-made cakes – because of food safety rules.

Maggie & John Molyneux Maggie & John Molyneux

As first revealed in the Welwyn Hatfield Times, John Molyneux, of Harmer Green, Digswell, was horrified when a letter from Isabel Hospice arrived telling his wife, Maggie, she could no longer bake cakes for the terminally-ill patients and their families.

The letter stated that from now on the cakes would be baked in a “controlled environment” by kitchen staff.

The 66-year-old told the Welwyn Hatfield Times: “They are doing away with a 23 year tradition of cakes being made by the local community for the hospice.

“When I called them about the letter, they told me they had never had a complaint.

“It’s 23 years’ of unblemished cake making.”

Mr Molyneux added that although his wife did not want to make a fuss, he was ‘incensed’ by the new rule.

“I am horrified, I am incensed by this and I think this is wrong,” he said.

“Are they going to ban cakes being sold at church fetes too?

“When is this madness going to end?”

The new rules have been brought in by Helen Dodd, director of the charity, to eliminate health risks to patients who use the hospice.

Although volunteers are no longer allowed to provide cakes for the hospice, they can still bake them to be sold at cake sales and fundraising events.

Mrs Dodd said: “For many years we have been grateful to our volunteers who have baked cakes for the patients at our in-patient unit in Welwyn Garden City.

“It is with great reluctance we have taken the decision to discontinue this practice, and in future to provide cakes baked on our own premises by our caterers.

“The reasons behind this decision are complex, but essentially we need to control the environment in which food is produced and to know the provenance of all ingredients used, as well as working within certain guidelines.

“Whilst this may seem extreme, it must be remembered we are caring for people who may have a suppressed immune system or other complications caused by their illness or treatment and it is, therefore, essential we do everything in our power to ensure their wellbeing.

“We have written to all our cake baking volunteers to thank them for their support and to explain the reasons for this decision. We very much hope they will continue to support Isabel Hospice by baking for events such as our Open Gardens.”


  • So it's okay to SELL the cakes through a function to anyone who might pass them on to their sick or dying relatives, but they can't be GIVEN to the hospice patients - Interesting!

    Report this comment


    Thursday, August 22, 2013

  • ps: God bless Maggie & John Molyneux, and your fellow volunteers x

    Report this comment


    Thursday, August 22, 2013

  • disgusting! patients of the hospice have gone there to die in a warm and caring environment, and hopefully, in a manner which enables them to pass away in peace, and in love. demonstrated by this couple, and others. this decision is cold, uncaring, and unloving. i respectfully request that this decision is repealed. the patients there are there to live until they die - do you really think, at worse, an upset tummy is really going to screw their day up? sort it out!!!

    Report this comment


    Thursday, August 22, 2013

  • so that me get this right, any money raising events and functions yes Helen Dodd will except the cakes home made but does not after all these years want someone who is near the end of their years to have a little bit of comfort with a homemade cake made with feeling and not full of gods know what. i think you Helen Dodd are a jobsworth and the power has gone to your head, how can you treat this couple and others like this, when they have given their heart and soul in making these to support the Isabell hospice and give your patients a bit of joy when facing a most awful time with pain etc. Shame on you Helen Dodd.

    Report this comment


    Thursday, August 22, 2013

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

More news stories

Yesterday, 17:51

Sir Roger Moore, who died of cancer this week aged 89, had a long association with filming in Hertfordshire and received an honorary degree from the county’s Hatfield-based university.

Yesterday, 17:35

Hatfield’s food bank for struggling people has relocated in the town centre.

Yesterday, 16:34

A distressed young deer got stuck under a garden shed in Welwyn Garden and had to be rescued by the RSPCA this morning.

Yesterday, 16:16

The clockwise carriageway of the M25 motorway was completely shut after an accident near Potters Bar during yesterday’s evening rush hour.

Digital Edition

Read the Welwyn Hatfield Times e-edition E-edition

Local business directory

Hertfordshire's trusted business finder

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most read stories


Show Job Lists

Herts Most Wanted Herts Business Awards